Although Silicon Valley has many Asian born immigrants and
descendants, a strong cultural Asian influence and is a relatively short commute
to China and Japan, Silicon Valley entrepreneurs and investors (SVEI) know surprisingly
little about how to successfully grow businesses in Asia or stimulate
investment from abroad into their companies.
As new technology firms realize that the opportunity is tapped in the
west, many are now looking towards Asia for growth and learning how to navigate
the Asian treasures.
Below is a snapshot of the cash balances of some of the
largest Internet and telecom companies in China and Japan:
Tencent: $40B
Alibaba: $30B (post-IPO)
Baidu: $6.37B
Qihoo: $2Bn
Rakuten: $4B
Softbank: $19B (post
Sprint)
Because many of these companies are US listed entities, analysts
and investors are putting pressure on these firms to continue growth in order
to uphold their stock prices. Similar to
their US counterparts, these technology companies have slowing growth in their
own markets. And for many of them it is
not just simply growth they want but it's the hubris of world domination and
not to be second to US technology firms like Google, Amazon, eBay, and
MSFT. In order for Asia to successfully
compete with these firms, these Asian firms are going to need the help of SV
technology startups. Both Asian
companies and US will benefit significantly in looking towards partnerships,
investments, and acquisitions.
For example, just last week, Alipay and Stripe concluded a
landmark deal, one of the first of its kind in the consumer Internet
space. This partnership is allegedly a
two-way partnership for Chinese consumers buying things overseas as well as US
consumers buying things in China. I'm not sure if I entirely buy that strategy but whatever is the actual objective, this is the beginning of a working relationship that will help Alipay to
understand the massive payment problem that Stripe is solving – the ability for
any merchant to accept credit cards online without the hassle of integrating a
payment service provider like Chase or a clunky Paypal. The Alipay – Stripe partnership
is a direct attack at Paypal. While
sitting in my hotel room in Riyadh, this news was rampant across every TV
channel throughout Asia. Its likely that this partnership ends up in a
acquisition of not less than $18bn – Mike Moritz will make a mark on the world with his last investment and will not be outdone by Jim Goetz’s Whatsapp deal.
Alibaba is not the only Chinese Internet firm seeking
partnerships abroad. Tencent and Baidu
are currently focusing on SE Asia, Middle East, and India as next expansion
steps since they are closer to home both geographically and culturally. Qihoo
is actively looking at partnerships in SV and looking to bring new technology
back to China. Chinese companies are now not only ready
to expand to the US but they are also seeking technology to bring back to
China.
Whereas Chinese companies may have been distrusted with
technology before, that distrust is now likely easing. One executive mentioned, “we are looking at
ways to sell more product to our 100M users back at home. We are running out of ideas and need partners
to help us.” This trend indicates that
Chinese companies are learning to understand the value of partnerships and
innovating together. One of the most obvious
examples of this is Riot Games – an American game company with astounding
success throughout Asia. Who would have
ever thought that an American game company would take a significant share of
the Chinese game market? Tencent saw the value in their product and community
and leveraged this when they brought the game to China. There was not even an attempt to copy the
game. One executive said, “We did not
have the time nor the knowledge to try to copy that game.” The $400M investment has been a smashing
success and Riot has continued to grow with revenues in the billions. This investment, two years ago, was a key
indicator of the coming Chinese investment.
And alas, many reading this blog would like the Chinese to
just buy their companies. As of yet, Chinese companies have not made any
multi-billing acquisitions in the US. But that will change soon. Only last month, Alibaba acquired app stores
UCweb for more than $2.1B in response to Baidu’s purchase of 91wireless for
$1.9B. In addition, Albibaba has been
investing in the US including Lyft, Shoprunner, and Tangome but have not closed
any major acquisitions as of yet. It’s
just a matter of time before they make some outright acquisitions. These indicate that the Chinese companies are
ready to make big acquisitions and the next ones will likely be overseas.
The Chinese are not the only active investor in SV. Over time, the Japanese have been a stalwart
investor in the US and their activity is continuing to grow. Rakuten acquired Viki and Viber for $300M and
$900M respectively. Other notable deals
include Softbank – Supercell ($1bn); DeNA- ngmoco ($300M); Gree – openfeint
($100M) & ); Gree – Funzio ($200M); Docomo-Buongiorno ($50M). Though DeNA and Gree have suffered a small
slow down in 2013, there are signs of them coming back in 2014. Gree’s new game
has recently taken over the #1 game slot held by Puzzles and Dragons for almost
2 years. For Rakuten, Docomo, and
Softbank, this is only the start of the acquisition spree for some of these companies
An acquisition may be the end goal for many startups but it’s
unlikely that the Japanese firms will lead with a heavy hand in all cases. It
is in the Japanese DNA particularly to try before they buy or take majority
shareholding positions while allowing founders to retain shares. Japanese firms often like to purchase just
over the 20% or 50% mark so that Japanese companies can accrete earnings to
their balance sheets. Recently I sat
down with the head of corporate development at one firm and he asked me about crowd
funding projects and all the cool new stuff in SV. He is clearly interested in
what the valley has to offer and what could be a platform for them to expand in
the west. Mitsui just invested in Box and aside from the larger companies, there are many other active strategic Japanese investors now including Sumitomo, Cyberagent, Recruit, Docomo Ventures, KDDI ventures, and GMO Ventures (leading payment gateway). SV should reach out to these
companies to better understand their investment thoughts.
Even with these positive indicators in mind, SVEI have
always had a tenuous relationship with the Japanese investors claiming they are
slow, too diligent, and have lengthy funding processes. Even recently one of the big Japanese acquirers
mentioned that they were not interested in SV because of this reputation and
felt like SV did not understand how to work with Japanese companies. They decided to avoid SV in favor of Europe and Israel – businesses who are naturally more global than businesses originated in SV. I
could sympathize with him because when I was at Mitsui, it was a constant fight
to get investors to let us in deals to prove our value. And this was in 2006 when there was a lot
less money in SV! (Cough cough - the Mitsui fund I worked for from 2006-2008 returned 10x their money with investments including IPOs Ruckus Wireless and A10 networks and acquisitions including Smart Signal (first internet of things before it was called that), and Beceem.
Even so, these slight annoyances should not detract from the
value Japanese partners can bring to SVEI.
Sunbridge Japan successfully expanded Sales force and Oracle into
Japan. The trading firms Mitsui and
Sumitomo have been actively investing in SVEI and bringing the technology back
to Japan. One of Mitsui’s investments,
A10 networks, recently went IPO off the back of significant revenues in Japan,
created by a small merger of one of Mitsui’s distribution channel companies. Carriers such as Softbank or KDDI have been great distribution partners
for startups. Softbank has partnered with Fon and Fitbit. KDDI has had several successful partnerships
like KKBox (Taiwanese startup created by a UCBerkeley graduate) distributing it
as an early leader for music streaming.
As young companies are looking abroad more aggressively, SVEI
should embrace the Chinese and Japanese in a much more meaningful way. While this post focused solely on internet and mobile companies, it is not limited to this industry. Clean energy, healthcare, and new hardware companies all will rely on Asia for growth and adoption of technology over the coming years. Asian investors cannot only invest they can
help build companies. SVEI should
allocate people to help build this bridge between the different countries;
business development associates should spend ample time scouting out
opportunities and developing partnerships. The future rewards will benefit all parties.